Senate defeat stalls crypto rules
Patrick Witt, the former executive director of the President’s Council of Advisers for Digital Assets, called the Senate defeat of the Clarity Act a "failure of American leadership." The bill failed a procedural vote in September after Witt spent over a year negotiating the regulatory framework. Witt, who left his administration role in October, said the midterm elections caused the "political issue of ethics" to consume the debate despite President Trump agreeing to two ethics provisions regarding his crypto holdings. Democrats raised concerns over the Trump family’s crypto ventures. Witt admitted Trump’s involvement was arguably the issue. One such provision would have forced the president to divest specific digital assets or place them in a blind trust and allowed state attorneys general to enforce violations. Another provision would have barred federal officials, including the president, from issuing or sponsoring digital assets. Witt said the policy resolved almost all differences, but the administration lost against the clock. The GENIUS stablecoin bill recovered after an initial procedural loss in 2025 because it arrived early in the Trump term, but Witt noted the administration only had one shot at the Clarity Act.
Agencies move to set standards
The defeat means U.S. crypto rules will be written in the Federal Register by the SEC and CFTC rather than on Capitol Hill. House Financial Services Committee Chairman French Hill said the current regulatory efforts fall short of the goals the legislation would have achieved. SEC Chair Paul Atkins and CFTC Chair Michael Selig intend to move markets on chain, which Witt says is necessary for American competitiveness because capital goes where it is treated best. Democrats won control of both chambers in this month’s midterms and are reportedly planning to push their own broader market structure bill. While Senator Elizabeth Warren remains opposed to anything favorable to crypto, younger lawmakers like Senators Angela Alsobrooks and Ruben Gallego view digital assets as part of the fabric of financial infrastructure. Witt expects market structure to be less written on Capitol Hill and more written by agencies through guidance. Lawmakers could still grant targeted powers, such as giving the Commodity Futures Trading Commission authority over spot crypto markets. Witt has held talks with crypto firms and defense companies.
