The verdict on Ethereum trading
Manhattan federal judge Jessica Clarke acquitted MIT-educated brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges regarding a $25 million Ethereum maximal extractable value (MEV) exploit. I find the acquittal decisive because the prosecution failed to prove the brothers made material misrepresentations while executing their trading strategy. They used bait transactions to manipulate sandwich bots. The prosecution’s case collapsed because they could not prove that the brothers’ use of bait transactions to manipulate sandwich bots constituted wire fraud under the specific statutes cited by the federal government. Judge Clarke ruled that the transactions did not occur on a regulated market where such conduct would be prohibited. She noted that the question of whether the strategy was improper or unethical was distinct from whether it constituted wire fraud. Their trading strategy targeted sandwich bots with bait transactions, a method that prosecutors tried to label as wire fraud. This ruling follows a November 2025 mistrial where the jury deadlocked in Manhattan federal court.
The April 2023 exploit and arrest
The legal case stems from an April 2023 incident where a group of MEV bots lost more than $25 million in seconds during a sophisticated attack on the Ethereum blockchain. The April 2023 attack replaced normal MEV transactions of the bots with malicious ones and caused them to lose money. Prosecutors arrested the Peraire-Bueno brothers in May 2024 after they alleged the brothers exploited the Ethereum blockchain. This exploitation involved maximal extractable value, which is the maximum amount of value a user or group can extract from a DeFi protocol or smart contract.
| Incident Detail | Value/Date |
|---|---|
| Total loss from exploit | $25 million |
| Date of bot exploit | April 2023 |
| Date of brothers’ arrest | May 2024 |
| Date of jury mistrial | November 2025 |
I view the prosecution’s attempt to criminalize these trading tactics as a massive overstep. Peter Van Valkenburgh, the executive director of Coin Center, called the case a "massive overstep" following the November 2025 mistrial in Manhattan. He told The Block that a jury would be "incredibly confused" if they were not crypto people. The case involved the way the brothers used the Ethereum blockchain to extract value from smart contracts. The investigation into the Peraire-Bueno brothers was based on the claim that they exploited Ethereum to extract value from DeFi protocols.
