Regulation

Supreme Court denies Custodia Bank petition for Fed master account

The Supreme Court rejected Custodia Bank's petition, upholding a ruling that the Federal Reserve has discretion over master account approvals. The decision ends a six-year legal battle by the Wyoming-chartered firm to gain direct access to the Federal Reserve's payment systems.

Supreme Court denies Custodia Bank petition for Fed master account

The Supreme Court denied Custodia Bank’s petition for a writ of certiorari, which leaves the previous ruling intact that the Federal Reserve Board has discretion to approve or deny master accounts for eligible institutions. This decision concludes a six-year legal effort by the Wyoming-chartered, crypto-focused firm to secure direct access to the Federal Reserve’s payment systems and U.S. money supply. The master account allows institutions direct access to the Fed’s payment systems and provides the most direct access to the U.S. money supply. Caitlin Long, a Wall Street veteran, founded Custodia Bank, which first applied for a master account in Kansas City in 2020. The Kansas City Fed denied the application in January 2023 because the regulator cited concerns about the bank’s crypto-related business model. Custodia sued the Kansas City Fed in June 2022. The lawsuit originally addressed a 19-month processing delay and later argued that federal law requires access for eligible institutions. An appeals court denied Custodia’s petition for rehearing en banc in March, which maintained the lower court’s decision. The bank petitioned the high court in July.

The Skinny Account Proposal

The decision arrives as interest grows in a "skinny master account" concept first proposed by Fed Governor Christopher Waller. This proposed account type would provide a tailored approach to mitigate risks, though some lawmakers question the safety and soundness of the Fed’s payment rails. The Fed asked for comments on the proposal last year. Crypto advocates called the proposal "overdue" in letters sent to the Fed. However, community banks warned that novel financial institutions do not follow the same "robust regulatory compliance regime" as traditional banks.

Proposed "skinny master account" feature Limit
Interest The Fed would not allow interest on balances
Borrowing The account could not access the discount window

Custodia Bank told the Supreme Court that a limited purpose account would not suffice because interest cannot be obtained on the account’s closing balance. This distinction remains a primary hurdle for firms that rely on interest-bearing accounts. Earlier this year, the banking division of Kraken became the first crypto company to obtain a master account. This account allows institutions direct access to the Fed’s payment systems and provides the most direct access to the U.S. money supply. Those without master accounts often rely on partner banks with master accounts to provide services.