2027 timeline for permanent rules
The SEC’s five-year innovation exemption clearly provides a window for the agency to learn which methods work before a 2027 proposal for permanent rules. SEC trading and markets director Jamie Selway expects his division to produce this proposal. He told host Laura Shin during an Unchained livestream on Monday that his division is framing the rules now. This regulatory timeline follows a five-year innovation exemption that the SEC issued on Sept. 17. This order allows new trading platforms, known as tokenized securities venues, to trade tokenized versions of listed stocks without registering as exchanges. These venues use automated market makers, which are software pools that set prices from their own reserves, to facilitate trades for a pool of approved users. The five-year limit on the exemption provides a helpful window for the agency to learn which methods work. He hopes the SEC can move from the exemption to rulemaking within a year or so. The SEC order covers only tokens that carry the full rights of the underlying share, which keeps out synthetic tokens that track a stock’s price but do not provide holders with the share itself. While the agency focuses on building in the U.S. under Chairman Paul Atkins, Selway said the SEC would take a look if investors suffer harm in offshore markets. He certainly would not "foreclose" the possibility that permanent rules extend to tokenized derivatives.
Risks of synthetic tokens
The current rules offer a clear advantage by excluding synthetic tokens, but Brett Redfearn, the president of tokenization firm Securitize, argues that synthetics carry "counterparty risk." He stated that if the issuer behind a synthetic fails, "that token holder isn’t holding anything anymore." Redfearn also argues against tokens that drop dividends or voting rights, and he told Shin that when the industry conducts tokenization, it should be "something more" and "better for investors."
| Feature | Status under current exemption |
|---|---|
| Underlying share rights | Required |
| Synthetic tokens | Excluded |
| Trading venue type | Automated market makers |
| User access | Approved users only |
OKXICE, a venue run by crypto exchange OKX and owner of the NYSE, Intercontinental Exchange, plans to open under the exemption on Nov. 23. This launch follows objections from dozens of companies regarding the listing of their shares. Selway said it is "extremely early" to judge the response to those objections.
