Regulation

Judge rejects CFTC request to block New York lawsuit against Kalshi

U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield denied the CFTC's second emergency request to stop New York Attorney General Letitia James from pursuing a lawsuit against prediction market exchange Kalshi. The court found the agency failed to show that federal law preempts New York state gaming laws.

Judge rejects CFTC request to block New York lawsuit against Kalshi

Federal judge rejects CFTC attempt to block New York enforcement

U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield rejected the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s second emergency request on Friday to stop New York Attorney General Letitia James from pursuing her lawsuit against the prediction market exchange Kalshi. This decision follows a July 31 ruling by U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff, who turned down the agency’s first emergency request to stop enforcement in New York. Justice Melissa Crane will hear a request for a temporary restraining order on Monday morning at 11:30 a.m. ET. Attorney Daniel Wallach noted that if Justice Crane adopts language prohibiting business "from New York," the case could reach the U.S. Supreme Court’s emergency docket. The CFTC and the Department of Justice sued New York in April over efforts to restrict prediction markets. The CFTC’s request for a preliminary injunction in that case has been pending since May. The CFTC argues the Commodity Exchange Act means prediction markets are federally regulated, but Schofield found the agency could not show a likelihood of success that the law preempted state gaming laws.

Kalshi faces nationwide operational halt

Letitia James seeks to bar Kalshi from operating an unlicensed gambling business that covers contracts on sports, culture, elections and other events. Kalshi lawyer Sean Murphy wrote to the court that because the exchange is based in New York, the order "would shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere" and "would likely force the liquidation of all open positions." The order also prohibits Kalshi from allowing users under 21 to trade or from advertising on college campuses. James’ office claims the order does not seek to "shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere" and will not stop Kalshi from offering lawful futures or swaps. On November 10, U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon called the order a "collusive effort between a regulator and regulatee to generate a claim for conflict preemption." In the Fourth Circuit, Judge Stephanie Thacker wrote that the contracts are not swaps. She stated, "What is happening here is sports betting." Judge Roger Gregory also ruled that federal law does not preempt Maryland’s gambling laws, even as the Fourth, Sixth and Ninth Circuits support states while the Third Circuit supports Kalshi. The CFTC asked New York to hold off on enforcement Friday morning, but the state declined.