Formal Rulemaking Demand
Kristin Johnson told the Senate Banking Committee on Nov. 19 that the SEC’s tokenized stock "innovation exemption" should undergo formal public comment. Johnson, President Trump’s nominee for the SEC and a former CFTC commissioner, said, "I feel strongly that regulation is made better through the notice and comment period" in response to Senator Angela Alsobrooks. She added that she would welcome taking the issues covered by the SEC’s order through that process. Jamie Selway, who heads the SEC’s Division of Trading and Markets, said the five-year term of the exemption was a design decision to keep the agency on the hook to do permanent rulemaking once the agency could figure out what works and what does not. Selway said his comments were his own and not the commission’s. Republican nominee Steven Levine told Senator Alsobrooks that many innovations, including exchange-traded funds, began as a series of exemptive orders that ultimately resulted in agency rulemaking so that there could be a standard process across the industry. Levine said he had not yet studied the exemption but understood it to include investor protections.
Industry Objections and Exemption Limits
At least 67 companies objected to having their shares traded on OKXICE, a joint venture between OKX and Intercontinental Exchange, according to a Nov. 5 public notice. The agency’s decision to bypass public input is clearly a mistake. The SEC issued the exemption on Sept. 17. This rule allows qualifying venues to trade tokenized versions of listed U.S. stocks onchain for five years without registering as exchanges. A company whose shares are tokenized by an unaffiliated third party gets 30 days to object. The exemption includes limits on volume and the number of stocks.
| Exemption Detail | Specification |
|---|---|
| Term Length | 5 years |
| Objection Window | 30 days |
| Asset Type | Tokenized U.S. stocks |
Senator Alsobroks led a letter last week with several colleagues to urge the SEC to reconsider the exemption. She said the agency allowed the exemption to "take effect immediately without any public input." Paul Atkins said that the interim measure must be followed by durable rulemaking after the agency figures out what works. Senator Mark Warner asked how basic anti-money laundering rules would be enforced for tokenized assets. Johnson pointed to investor protection and AML compliance concerns. Senator Raphael Warnock said that if both nominees are confirmed, the commission will have three Republicans and one Democrat. The SEC currently has no Democratic commissioners.
