Regulation

Lawmakers introduce bill to combat insider trading in prediction markets

Representatives Sean Casten and Ted Lieu introduced the Policing Insider Trading in Prediction Markets Act to create a whistleblower program for reporting fraud. The legislation follows reports of a U.S. Army soldier using confidential information to place bets on Polymarket.

Lawmakers introduce bill to combat insider trading in prediction markets

Rep. Sean Casten and Rep. Ted Lieu introduced the Policing Insider Trading in Prediction Markets Act to establish a Justice Department program where whistleblowers report fraud anonymously and receive compensation for successful enforcement. Casten, who may hold a top congressional position next year, said, "Prediction markets have a serious insider trading problem, and the current Administration is engaged in corruption of epic proportions." This legislation follows specific reports of misconduct where an active-duty U.S. Army soldier used confidential information to place bets on Polymarket before the capture of former Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro. Other concerns involve allegations that a former White House teleprompter operator and various political candidates exploited access to nonpublic information for financial gain. On Thursday, the Senate passed the Death Bets Act to ban prediction market contracts tied to terrorism, assassination, war, and death. I find the push for a whistleblower program necessary because these incidents of military and government officials using private information for profit undermine the rule of law. With Democrats set to take control of Congress in January, Sen. Elizabeth Warren will focus on these markets, while Casten challenges Maxine Waters for the leadership of the House Financial Services Committee.

Industry debate on regulation

At The Hill and The Block’s Capitol Crypto Forum, Kalshi board member Brian Quintenz argued that insider trading appears more direct and visible in prediction markets than in the stock market. Quintenz said there are far more insider trading cases in the stock market than in the derivatives or prediction market space. He noted that enforcement should supplement the work exchanges do to prevent violations, but he also said that the CFTC must clarify how it applies the standard of whether a contract is readily susceptible to manipulation. Dan Berkovitz, a former CFTC commissioner, said federal rules already prohibit insider trading, but he noted that mention markets allow individuals to control contract outcomes by deciding whether to say a specific word or phrase. He argued that exchanges need participation limits and strict anti-manipulation provisions to address those with influence or control over a contract.

Christy Goldsmith Romero, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and former CFTC commissioner, said that exchanges act as the first line of defense against insider trading, but she suggested the CFTC should provide more clarity to assist them. She also predicted that prediction markets might lose on sports contracts and that the SEC could increase its involvement as these platforms offer more contracts related to public companies. Regarding the regulation of sports contracts, Berkovitz said the post-Dodd-Frank final rule continues to prohibit gaming contracts via the CFTC, although the latest interim rule distinguishes between casino gambling and products listed for trading on a federally regulated exchange. He added that a legal question remains over whether the same product can be treated as a swap on one platform but not another. Quintenz said he submitted a comment letter in his personal capacity and noted that the Supreme Court’s 2018 sports betting ruling did not give states exclusive authority. Goldsmith Romero added that the Supreme Court would likely take up the sports matter given the conflicting decisions across the Circuit Courts, and she said both the SEC and CFTC should work together to provide more clarity.