Essential clarity for developers
I find CryptoUK’s push to separate software maintenance from regulated activities essential for the industry. The trade group submitted its response to the Financial Conduct Authority consultation paper CP26/36 on Wednesday, November 18, and published the document on November 19. CryptoUK, which includes more than 150 crypto companies, argues that software development, maintenance, security work and participation in decentralised governance should not, by themselves, establish that a person carries on a regulated activity. This position matches the FCA’s own "clear controlling person" approach to DeFi. I clearly prefer this logic because it keeps the focus on who actually controls a financial service rather than just who writes the code. The group, with policy director Nick Brooks and law firm CMS, seeks to ensure developers do not face regulation by default.
Flaws in the draft guidance
The draft guidance, which the FCA intends to publish in January 2027, contains flaws that I find troubling. While CryptoUK broadly supports the guidance and the legislative amendments from September, the group claims parts of the draft "goes further than the legislation." Specifically, CryptoUK objects to a proposed link to the UK based on where developers build or govern a protocol. The group also criticizes indicators that narrow the exclusion for technical services. The group wants the FCA to ask the Treasury to address outcomes that disadvantage UK firms, such as the treatment of UK technical providers offering access to regulated overseas trading venues.
| Excluded Activities |
|---|
| Temporary settlement and payment arrangements |
| Assets backing UK-recognized stablecoins |
| Proprietary trading and market making |
| Technical service providers |
I find the group’s criticism of the narrow technical services exclusion and the treatment of payments using stablecoins issued abroad to be valid. CryptoUK also asked for a public record of stablecoins that qualify under the UK regime and more examples of activities that fall outside the perimeter. The regulator finalized core rules for crypto firms in June. This leads to a regime due to take effect on October 25, 2027. The FCA has already acknowledged that the timing of the latest amendments created uncertainty for some firms, and the regulator said it will give applicants extra time where questions over the technical services exclusion held up their applications for authorization. CryptoUK wants the UK to align with the EU’s MiCA framework "where appropriate." The FCA has also set out a shared vision for tokenization with the Bank of England.
