Security

Aztec CEO says advanced AI models could find bugs in Tierra network

Aztec CEO Zac Williamson admits advanced AI models may discover bugs in the Tierra privacy network after an internal AI audit harness identified vulnerabilities that human auditors missed in the previous V5 version.

Aztec CEO says advanced AI models could find bugs in Tierra network

AI finding bugs

Aztec CEO Zac Williamson admits he "can’t rule out the possibility that bugs will be found by more advanced AI models" in Aztec Tierra, the Ethereum privacy network that launched its Alpha V6 version on Nov. 3. I find his admission necessary because the team’s internal AI audit harness found vulnerabilities in the previous V5 version that human audits missed. In August, Aztec disclosed a flaw in the V5 proving system that could have allowed a forged proof to pass, adding they could not tell whether anyone had used the bug. Williamson said the team has formally verified only the most security-critical code, and for now, every major upgrade requires users to withdraw and redeposit so a hidden double-spend cannot carry over. Williamson noted in an interview on Unchained Premium that AI audits on the previous version turned up "some criticals" in its cryptographic libraries. According to an Oct. 15 post he co-wrote, the AI audit harness found vulnerabilities that human audits missed. Only the "most security critical parts" have undergone formal verification to mathematically prove the code does what it should, which he says implies the bug the AI found was the last bug in that particular subsystem.

Risk management and network upgrades

Aztec manages the risk of double-spend attacks, where users spend the same funds twice without the network being able to observe the theft, through a specific upgrade process. Williamson says attackers can deploy "millions of AI bots." Because privacy networks make these bugs difficult to detect, Williamson uses major network upgrades as complete hard forks to force users to withdraw from old versions and deposit into new ones. This process ensures that a hidden double-spend in the old version cannot extend to the new version of Aztec, a strategy Williamson says makes Aztec "absolute best in class" for managing such risks, similar to the turnstile accounting used by Zcash.

Feature Status/Detail
Current Version Tierra (Alpha V6)
Launch Date Nov. 3
Security Rating Stage 2 (ETHBEAT)
Security Council None

ETHBEAT, formerly L2BEAT, rates the V6 version as Stage 2 and notes it is a fresh start with no state carried over from V5. Aztec Labs also relaunched its zk.money payments wallet on the network in September. I find the lack of a security council a weakness, though Williamson says the long-term solution is formal verification.