The STRC repurchase drain
Strategy used $206 million of last week’s $228 million STRC buy-back through MSTR dilution, leaving only $332 million of the $3 billion total authorized repurchase fund available as of November 15. This 89% depletion follows a period where Strategy spent $1.4 billion more after an earlier $2 billion authorization was 64% exhausted by September 28. I see this as a failed attempt to support the stock. STRC closed Wednesday at its lowest finish since August 20 and 3.9% below the $100 target. Saylor called keeping STRC near $100 "the company’s number one business objective" in May, but the continuous dilution of MSTR common shareholders to fund these STRC preferreds provides no relief. The company aims to hold STRC near $100 while paying ultra-high dividends, but the current price remains below that target.
Bitcoin losses and Saylor’s targets
Strategy’s Bitcoin gamble produced a $10.9 billion unrealized loss because the company spent $64.2 billion to acquire 850,849 BTC worth only $53.3 billion. Strategy also spent more than $1 billion in expenses to operate this unrealized loss-generating colossus. Since Saylor declared the "beginning of the next bitcoin bull market" on October 29, BTC fell 19% and MSTR dropped 36%. I find the $1 billion in operating expenses for a company generating such massive unrealized losses to be a blatant waste of capital. Although Strategy holds $4.9 billion in cash, the board likely won’t use it to offset half the loss. I also find it telling that Saylor works in the business of selling stock to buy MSTR.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| BTC purchase cost | $64.2 billion |
| Current BTC value | $53.3 billion |
| Unrealized loss | $10.9 billion |
| MSTR 5-year rally | 24% |
| BTC 5-year rally | 7% |
The 24% rally for MSTR over the last five years fails to reach Saylor’s 30% annual target, especially since BTC only rallied 7% in that same period. While MSTR investors waited five years, they received less than a single year’s worth of Saylor’s annual target. Saylor told investors on Wednesday that seller exhaustion would arrive long before his own exhaustion. He receives executive perks regardless of the underperformance of MSTR and STRC. Strategy scheduled an investor Q&A with Saylor and CEO Phong Le for Thursday at 5pm New York time.
